Wood Burning Fire Pits vs. Gas Fire Pits: Which is Better?

A backyard fire pit isn’t just a warm place to gather; it’s the heart of your outdoor living space. Whether you’re hosting friends for a cozy evening or roasting marshmallows with the kids, the right setup can transform your experience.

But instead of asking which fire pit is "better," let’s explore how each type fits different lifestyles and how the right accessories from Walden Backyards can elevate any fire pit experience.

Wood Burning Fire Pits: The Classic Backyard Experience

There’s a reason wood-burning fire pits have been a backyard staple for generations. The crackle of logs, scent of burning wood, and open flame offer an unmatched rustic ambiance.

Why Choose a Wood-Burning Fire Pit?

Authentic Campfire Feel
The natural flame, smoky aroma, and satisfying crackle deliver a traditional, sensory-rich experience.

High Heat Output
Wood-burning fire pits often generate more heat, making them a favorite for chilly nights.

Perfect for Cooking
Enjoy roasting hot dogs or making s’mores the old-fashioned way. Just add a cooking grate or cast iron accessories.

Affordable Options
These fire pits typically have lower upfront costs and come in portable and DIY-friendly formats.

What to Consider

Maintenance
Expect to remove ash, clean soot, and store dry firewood.

Startup Time
Lighting a wood fire takes some patience and the right tools.

Smoke and Emissions
Burning wood produces smoke and can leave behind strong scents.

Gas Fire Pits: Convenience and Clean Flames

Gas fire pits bring ease and consistency to your backyard gatherings. They’re ideal for those who prioritize simplicity and sleek design.

Why Choose a Gas Fire Pit?

Instant Ignition
Start the fire with the turn of a knob or the press of a remote.

Low Maintenance
With no ash or soot, cleanup is minimal.

Consistent Flame and Heat Control
Control flame size and intensity with ease.

Versatile Placement
Safe for use on patios, decks, and under covered areas where wood fire pits may not be permitted.

Modern Designs
Gas pits are available in a wide variety of stylish designs to match contemporary outdoor decor.

What to Consider

Higher Upfront Cost
Installing a gas fire pit, especially with a gas line, requires a higher initial investment.

Limited Cooking Uses
While you can toast marshmallows, cooking over gas flames is not recommended for greasy foods.

Fuel Needs
You’ll need propane tanks or a natural gas connection, depending on the model.

Don’t Forget the Accessories

No matter which fire pit you prefer, the real magic comes from the accessories that enhance your experience. Walden Backyards offers high-quality gear to help you start fires faster, cook easier, and keep your setup looking beautiful.

Top Accessories from Walden Backyards

Walden Fire Starter Packs
Say goodbye to kindling frustration. These all-natural starters ignite easily, even in damp conditions.

Walden Steel Grates
Add one to your wood fire pit for a safe, even cooking surface. Perfect for campfire meals.

Spark Screens
Protect your space from stray embers while still enjoying a clear view of the flames.

Ash Scoops and Cleaning Tools
Make post-fire cleanup quick and mess-free.

Premium Firewood Bundles
Pre-cut and seasoned for optimal burn. Ready for your next night under the stars.

Explore all accessories here: Shop Fire Pit Accessories

Environmental Considerations

If you're focused on sustainability, both options have tradeoffs.

Wood is renewable but produces more smoke and particulates.
Natural Gas burns cleaner but is fossil-fuel based.
Bioethanol fire pits offer an eco-friendly, plant-based alternative.

Regardless of your fire type, using responsibly sourced wood and fire starters helps minimize environmental impact.

Safety First

Wood Fire Pit Safety Tips

      • Position at least 25 feet from buildings and trees

      • Use a spark screen

      • Fully extinguish fires after use

      • Store firewood in a dry place away from flames

Gas Fire Pit Safety Tips

      • Inspect gas lines annually

      • Never leave gas running unattended

      • Use long-reach lighters or electronic ignitions

      • Install wind guards for safer flames

What Fits Your Lifestyle?

Choose Wood-Burning If You:

      • Love traditional campfire vibes

      • Want higher heat output

      • Enjoy outdoor cooking

      • Have room for storing wood

      • Don’t mind regular cleanup

Choose Gas If You:

      • Prefer low-fuss fires

      • Need cleaner operation

      • Want to use your fire pit in a compact space

      • Like modern aesthetics and instant control

Final Thoughts: Accessories Make the Experience

It’s not just about choosing a fire pit. It’s about how you use it. Whether you lean toward a traditional wood burner or a clean-burning gas pit, you can always enhance the experience with the right accessories.

At Walden Backyards, we focus on what matters most turning ordinary backyards into extraordinary places to gather. Shop our selection of premium fire pit accessories and create your ideal setup, no matter what kind of fire pit you own.

FAQs: Gas vs. Wood Fire Pits

1. Which fire pit produces more heat?

Wood-burning fire pits typically generate more heat.

2. Can I cook on a gas fire pit?

You can roast marshmallows, but greasy foods aren't recommended.

3. Which is easier to maintain?

Gas fire pits are virtually maintenance-free compared to wood models.

4. Which accessories are essential for a wood-burning fire pit?

Fire starters, spark screens, and ash scoops are must-haves for both safety and performance.